Kim Stanley Robinson. Red Moon

Cross-posted from C4SS.

I had Kim Stanley Robinson’s Red Moon on my Goodreads to-read list for a long time, mainly because I’m a fan of his other work and the title sounded evocative. But I put off reading it time and again because the Goodreads summary didn’t give much indication of how much systemic transition figured in the plot — in fact it’s got even more of that than New York 2140 — and gave the impression it was mostly a hoodunit. 

The story takes place in 2047, against the backdrop of rising unrest and crises of legitimacy in both China and the United States — in China against the perception that socialism is long dead and the state is the instrument of an oligarchy of billionaires and hereditary Party elites, and in the United States that representative democracy is similarly long-dead and the American government is owned by billionaires and corporations. As one of the characters observes, a system cannot remain in power long-term if a majority of the population it rules consider it fundamentally illegitimate; the American and Chinese systems lasted as long as they did for that reason. But both the United States government and Chinese People’s Republic were being rocked by the greatest popular uprisings and fundamental threats to their constitutional orders in their history, because the public perceived them to have lost the Mandate of Heaven.

In the United States a Householder’s Union, very similar to the one in New York 2140 but a century earlier, has grown to claim 200 million members — many or most of whom are engaged in a strike withholding rent, mortgage, debt, and tax payments from the regime. In both the United States and China, the dissidents are mass-withdrawing money from the banks — causing bank runs, insolvency, and the immediate prospect of nationalization in the US — and putting it into a cryptocurrency called “carboncoin,” which is created by verifiably removing CO2 from the atmosphere and can be used to purchase only sustainably produced subsistence goods.  

That the millions of backers of this new currency were also demanding blockchain governance only added to the worries of people in power everywhere.

“Do you understand this idea of blockchain governance?” Ta Shu asked John Semple at one point.

John shrugged. “1 think the idea is that if everyone’s got a wristpad and a connection to the cloud, everyone could participate in some kind of global governance, in which every action legal and financial would be completely documented, and recorded and secured publicly step by step and law by law.”

* * *

Blockchain governance is an algorithmically assisted direct democracy, or a representative government in which the representatives are in part algorithmic.

In the United States, at the climax of the story, nationwide demonstrations include four million people in Washington DC alone. In China, the entire Beijing region has been shut down by tens of millions people, basically everyone within a day’s walking distance swarming the capital; the state is paralyzed, simply trying to outwait the demonstrators.

The central viewpoint character is Chan Qi — or rather, perhaps, her traveling companion Fred Fredericks, whose main role is apparently to observe her on behalf of the reader. Chan is a “Party princess,” black sheep daughter of one of the members of the Politburo standing committee contending to succeed the current leader. She is also the most important underground leader of the Chinese dissident movement, mostly referred to as the New Left; its primary constituency is “the billion,” aka migrant rural laborers living and working illegally in the cities, aka the “three withouts,” and its ideology is a vaguely left-communist amalgam of neo-Maoism and liberal democracy. Their goal is for Party and state to genuinely represent the people as in the imagined past, for them to genuinely pursue an egalitarian project of socialist construction that improves lives for the destitute classes, and for arbitrary government to be replaced by the rule of law and genuine procedural guarantees. Like the American Householders Union, the New Left seeks to organize its neo-Maoist economic and political framework around carboncoin and blockchain governance.

Chan and Fredericks, like the central characters in fictional content from Shaft to Gorky Park, spend the entire novel in hiding in one place after another on the earth and the moon, fleeing an unknown enemy in a struggle of warring factions whose are largely unknown, with the help of various seeming friends whose true interests are also largely unknown. 

The Chinese Party-state is riddled with a Byzantine maze of political factions, including various members of the Politburo standing committee engaged in a succession struggle, along with a host of rogue security and intelligence agencies and rogue factions within them carrying out unauthorized operations for political reasons of their own. The surveillance state itself is fractured and Balkanized, with spotty and incomplete coverage and poor coordination and collation of data between the various agencies. The main bad guys pursuing Chan and Fredericks, Red Spear, are an ultra-militant faction within a security agency, allied to the most conservative of the Politburo standing committee members contending for power.

Chan and Fredericks, meanwhile, are aided by friendly forces ranging from other candidates for succession in the Politburo Standing Committee and their allies in the bowels of various state agencies, to autonomous actors on the moon, to rogue actors within the American security apparatus.

At the moment of climax, the two most important focal points in the Chinese political maelstrom were Chan Qi, leader of the mass resistance movement, and Peng Ling, a progressive member of the Politburo standing committee who was contending to become the first woman Party General Secretary and state President, moderately sympathetic to the movement’s aims. 

For most of the story Peng has aided Chan from a distance with the help of allies embedded in various bureaucratic apparatuses on the earth and on the moon — at various times having Chan and Fredericks taken into protective custody by security forces loyal to her, or securing the aid of local allies to free them from arrest by hostile security forces working with Red Spear — but the aid has been sporadic and poorly coordinated.

The catalyst who brings this loose constellation of forces together is “Little Eyeball,” an AGI programmed by an unnamed intelligence analyst sympathetic to Chan Qi and the resistance. When the analyst is arrested, Little Eyeball begins, pursuant to his prior instructions, to act autonomously in infiltrating the entire Party-state information infrastructure seeking out ways to aid the resistance on its own initiative. It swarms Party, state, and resistance actors with thousands of messages attempting to coordinate action and galvanize it in a successful direction.

As all this is happening, Peng Ling is elected to the positions of President, Party General Secretary, and Chair of the Military Commission. Chan Qi’s father, who apparently has been an ally of Peng’s for some time, is elected Premier. With the help of Little Eyeball, Peng makes contact with Chan, in hiding following a failed Red Spear assassination attempt on her lunar rover. Peng persuades Chan Qi to cooperate and attempt to calm the resistance down, in return for a promise of reforms. Chan agrees, sending out the message “People. Chan Qi here. Good work so far. Let the new leadership enact the reforms. Stay vigilant. See if the new leadership will represent us. Stay vigilant!” It’s a bit like if Wat Tyler had negotiated with Richard II, but Richard had been mildly favorable to the rebellion and acting in good faith.

As the story ends Chan Qi, still on the run from surviving elements of Red Spear lashing out in revenge, receives word that Peng has announced major economic reforms like a restoration of the Iron Rice Bowl (the guaranteed job security, with living wage and benefits, that existed before Deng’s reforms), but is backpedaling on political reforms like rule of law and dismantling the surveillance state. Meanwhile, the Householders Union has launched itself on a global scale, inducted four billion new members, and issued carboncoin stipends to its entire membership.

I enjoyed the account of the Chinese and American resistance movements in this story as much as the similar American movement in New York 2140, and the decentralized and barely statelike Martian state in the Mars Trilogy. The Martian polity in the latter series, after achieving independence, was basically a global federation of communes, direct democracies, and city-states. The basic egalitarian goals of the polity were built into the initial property rules — land was a social commons, and all enterprises were automatically worker-owned — rather than achieved through regulation. Indeed the state was more of a support platform than a state, with almost nothing in the way of positive regulatory authority; its activities consisted almost entirely of judicial enforcement of the property rules and guaranteed basic human rights. This is the kind of thing Robinson is good at writing about.

The lessons from Red Moon, for anarchists, are that the state can be usefully pressured from below, but we cannot trust it; that we should take advantage of whatever reforms it offers and build them, but continue to pressure it from below — and that we should continue acting outside it to build the kind of society we want, without asking for permission. Above all, that “revolution” is not an event, but an ongoing process that never ends.

The Caryatids, by Bruce Sterling

[Cross-posted from P2P Foundation Blog]

The Caryatids. Bruce Sterling. Del Rey, 2009

By way of caveat, let me get out front with the admission that this review involves mainly aspects of the “future history” scenario I find most intriguing, rather than with the story line or characters. While I can get into a good story, I generally read near-future sci fi with a view primarily to the usable ideas for organizing society or for explaining the direction things are going in.

The Caryatids is set in the world of 2065, a world wrecked by global warming, in which most states have been pushed to overload and collapse by the ecological catastrophes of the early 21st century.

The world is dominated by two networked global civil societies, the Dispensation and the Acquis. Both are engaged in the reclamation of devastated areas and oversee networks of refugee camps housing millions of displaced persons.

The Acquis is largely green and open-source in ideological orientation, and the Dispensation is commercial and proprietary.

Continue reading →

Cory Doctorow. Walkaway

Cory Doctorow (2017). Walkaway. New York: Tor (cross-posted from C4SS.org)

I.

The story opens at a communist party in an unspecified post-industrial town in Ontario sometime in the late middle of this century, from the first-person perspective of Hubert, Etc. A communist party, you should understand, is not an institution but a social event: something like a rave at an abandoned factory where, along with dancing, drinking, drugs, and hookups, illegal acts of post-scarcity are committed. In this case, which is presumably typical, the temporarily recuperated facility is a furniture factory with machinery that’s apparently user-friendly enough a random assortment of intoxicated teens and twenty-somethings can get it up and running and turn out fairly large runs of shelving, beds, or whatever. Using the abandoned machinery and large amounts of abandoned feedstock, one communist party can “do enough furnishings for a couple thousand families” in one evening. The next party is scheduled for a feedstock plant in a neighboring town to keep the supply chain going. And so on.

As Natalie — an attendee at the communist party who becomes a main character — describes it, the whole point of it all is post-scarcity.

Look… at all this. On paper, this place is useless; the stuff coming off that line has to be destroyed. It’s a trademark violation: even though it came off an official Muji line, using Muji’s feedstock, it doesn’t have Muji’s official license, so that configuration of cellulose and glue is a crime. That’s so manifestly fucked up and shit that anyone who pays attention to it is playing the wrong game and doesn’t deserve consideration.

Continue reading →

Neal Stephenson: The Diamond Age

Neal Stephenson. The Diamond Age: or, a Young Lady’s Illustrated Primer (1995). Cross-posted from C4SS.

In Four Futures Peter Frase poses, as a thought experiment, an “anti-Star Trek”: a world that shares the same technologies as Star Trek: The Next Generation‘s post-scarcity communist society, but in which those technologies of abundance are enclosed with intellectual property barriers so that capitalists can continue to live off the rents of artificial scarcity.

“…[I]magine that unlike Star Trek, we don’t all have access to our own replicators. And that in order to get access to a replicator, you would have to buy one from a company that licenses the right to use it. You can’t get someone to give you a replicator or make one with their replicator, because that would violate their license and get them in legal trouble.

What’s more, every time you make something with the replicator, you also need to pay a licensing fee to whoever owns the rights to that particular thing. Captain Jean-Luc Picard customarily walks to the replicator and requests “tea, Earl Grey, hot.” But his anti-Star Trek counterpart would have to pay the company that has copyrighted the replicator pattern for hot Earl Grey tea.”

In such a world, earning the money to pay for the things will be a problem, since there is no need for labor to actually make anything. What remaining work there is will be a small pool of intensely competed-for jobs designing stuff, some amount of guard labor enforcing intellectual property against piracy and protecting the accumulated property of the rich, and an odd assortment of work in household service or hand-crafting luxury goods for those in the propertied classes who value the status symbolism entailed in such things.

This is the world of The Diamond Age.
Continue reading →

Review of Peter Frase’s Four Futures

[Cross-posted from C4SS]

 Peter Frase. Four Futures: Life After Capitalism (London and New York: Verso, 2016).

Frase’s book builds on Rosa Luxemburg’s prediction a hundred years ago in the Junius Pamphlets that “[b]ourgeois society stands at the crossroads, either transition to socialism or regression into barbarism.” Specifically, he sketches — in very broad strokes — two versions of socialism and two versions of barbarism as possible alterative futures all resulting from large-scale automation. As Frase himself admits, “my approach is deliberately hyperbolic, sketching out simplified ideal types,” or “simplified, pure models…, designed to illuminate a few key issues that confront us today and will confront us in the future.”

Popular press treatments of automation, Frase notes, range from pessimistic predictions of technological unemployment to “liberal bromides” about “entrepreneurship and education.” But all of them are missing one thing: “politics, and specifically class struggle.”

This outlook ignores the central defining features of the society we live in: capitalist class and property relations. Who benefits from automation, and who loses, is ultimately not a consequence of the robots themselves but of who owns them.

Continue reading →

Ami Angelwings on the Utopianism of Star Trek TNG

Ami Angelwings noted that Q chose Picard to test, as a representative specimen of humanity, because as a personality he illustrates the biggest change from what he’d have been in the past (reformatted into paragraph form from @Ami_Angelwings Twitter, May 7, 2015):

I realized that the reason Q tests Picard, is that he represents the part of “humanity” that they need to see has evolved from the past. While we know him as an intelligent mature guy, he was a brash womanizer as a kid, who got into fights & loved em & left em. He left home, only freshman to win the marathon, he became the youngest captain, he has all these gary stu heroic stories. He’s a white straight cis male who shot to the top, he’s not the smartest guy, even as an explorer he’s still a military commander. Geordi could’ve solved the paradox, Crusher could’ve solved Farpoint. Point is that in other times, Picard would be the privileged oppressor. The test isn’t can ANY human expand their mind to figure out a paradox, or can ANY human have the compassion to solve Farpoint? The test is “can your white cis straight dude captain with the gary stu past who commands the strongest ship, figure that stuff out?”

Reading Between the Lines of Star Trek TNG’s Utopianism

[A dialogue with Josh Marsfelder of Vaka Rangi blog, based on a Twitter exchange. My comments are in bold.]

The Federation’s attitude towards treaty obligations in Ensigns of Command, The Vengeance Factor and The Hunted seems to value an interstellar equivalent of the Westphalian nation-state for its own sake. Put that together with the Prime Directive, and the central value of the Federation seems to be stasis. Reminds me a lot of George Bush standing by & letting Saddam suppress the Shia/”Marsh Arab” uprising in Iraq after the war.
Yeah, that sounds about right to me. Do bear in mind where the Enterprise crew’s values stood in relation to that though. And also how Captain Picard’s description of life in the 24th Century in “The Neutral Zone” seems to contradict that. Or, for that matter, the sheer number of times the crew have been put up against Starfleet Command/Federation administration. Once you get to TNG Mark II and DS9, you’ll see how the war with Cardassia might have given the Feds a reason to act that way. A four year war about petty border disputes where entire planetary populations were used as bargaining chips by both sides. Continue reading →

Behind the DRM Curtain: Three Cory Doctorow Stories

[Note — this is crossposted from C4SS].

These three short stories all come from the same Cory Doctorow collection, Overclocked: Stories of the Future Present St (New York: Thunder’s Mouth Press, 2007). Free download here. The three are all set against a background of what I call the “DRM Curtain,” a transnational corporate Empire based on artificial scarcities enforced through a maximalist version “intellectual property” rights, promoted through trade deals written and lobbied by the proprietary content industries, and ultimately backed by the military force of the American state. The DRM Curtain’s corporate ruling class is as dependent on police state surveillance and the restriction of information flow as was the bureaucratic oligarchy that ruled the old Soviet empire behind the Iron Curtain.

Continue reading →